Skip to content
coworkplugins

Claude skill

Critic Review

Critic Review is a Claude skill in the Mad Science plugin. Review the project docs and experiments for gaps between what is documented, what was implemented, and the state of the art.

CommunityShips in Mad ScienceData Analysis

What it does

The description in the skill's SKILL.md, which Claude reads to decide when to use it:

Review the project docs and experiments for gaps between what is documented, what was implemented, and the state of the art. Use when the user wants a critical assessment of the whole project, wants to check for missing experiments, bad assumptions, or weak evidence.

How to use it

  1. Critic Review comes inside the Mad Science plugin, so you get it by installing that plugin, along with its 13 other skills. A plugin installs as one unit, with all its skills. The plugin's page has the install steps, and plugins are saved to your Claude account.
  2. Ask Claude for the task. When your request matches the skill's description, Claude loads it.
  3. To pick it yourself in Claude chat, type / or click + and choose critic-review. In Claude Code and Cowork, type:
    /mad-science:critic-review

Source

Plugin
Mad Science
SKILL.md
View on GitHub
Repo stars
2
Repo last pushed
Nov 11, 2026
Checked
Nov 16, 2026

More skills in Mad Science